Wyatt works at a video store with a girl named Kensington. The two of them do not get along, and when Wyatt says the wrong thing to the girl, he ends up walking home earlier than he had anticipated. On his way home, he notices a car parked in a strange location, and he recognizes the car as Mrs. Prezar's, a snobby rich woman who Wyatt once mowed lawns for. He recognizes the vehicle easily, as he had seen the car at the hardware store across from the video store only hours earlier. Mrs. Prezar had been acting strange when Wyatt watched her enter the hardware store and then briskly exit only a few moments later, which makes Wyatt feel unsettled as he approaches the car. As he gets closer, Wyatt sees Mrs. Prezar's baby in the back seat, but something is wrong. Then, as Wyatt moves towards the open driver's door, he sees Mrs. Prezar herself...
I really enjoyed this short story, because I felt that Joe Hill did an excellent job of utilizing surprise. As the story progressed, I never expected Wyatt to encounter Mrs. Prezar in the way he did, but all of the details leading up to the event made sense once he did. Even as the intense segments of the story occurred, Joe Hill made me question the motives of the characters involved, to the point that I am not sure if certain characters are actually good or bad. This possibility for dual interpretations might leave some readers dissatisfied, but I found it refreshing. The story wraps up nicely, as it ties in earlier themes, but leaves that opening for interpretation without making the reader feel like there were loose ends left hanging. Joe Hill is definitely an author that I will look forward to reading again after reading this strong short story.
"In the Rundown" can be found in the short story collection 20th Century Ghosts, which consists of short stories written by Joe Hill.